 |
||||||
| Home >> Book Reviews >> The Indian in the Cupboard | ||||||
 |
The Indian in the Cupboard Review
It all starts with a birthday present Omri doesn't even want -- a small plastic Indian of no use to him at all. But when an old wooden cupboard and a special key bring the unusual toy to life, Omri's Indian becomes his most important secret: precious, dangerous, wonderful, and above all, magical. User Submitted The Indian in the Cupboard ReviewsNovember 10, 2008 Quick service All books were new as requested. I was really surprised that the books were received so quickly. Great service! I will purchase from this person again. July 3, 2008 Good Writing- Appaling Content As an educator, I am appalled when I find out that other teachers still use this book in their classrooms without discussing the egregious misrepresentation of Native Americans throughout this book. While this book has won critical acclaim for its writing, no level of fine writing will make up for the damage it does to the image of Native Americans. This book portrays Native Americans as unintelligent savages who are ready to attack at any moment. I cringe to think of the Native child who reads this book and self-worth is shattered! August 6, 2007 Interesting story It's Omri's birthday and his brother and his friend have gotten him gifts that don't seem like the best gifts in the world. His brother gave him a cupboard that he found in an alley. And his friend, Patrick, gave him a plastic Indian figure. There's nothing too magical about these items and Omri is less than interested in them until he finds a key among his mother's extra keys that fits the cupboard. He finds that when he puts a plastic figure in the cupboard and then locks the cupboard with that particular key, the figure comes to life! With a little experimenting, he finds that if he then locks the live figure back in, it returns to its original form. Now Omri has a live Indian (a very small live Indian) living in his room. Sounds pretty neat, huh? Well, Omri soon finds out that it's not so easy to be responsible for another human being no matter how small they are. The Indian's name is Little Bear and he makes demands on Omri such as asking for supplies to make a longhouse, paint for decorations and - most importantly - food. Omri has to go to great lengths to help Little Bear while at the same time keeping the Indian a secret from his family and friends. When he finally does tell his friend, Patrick, Omri regrets it. Patrick wants to play with the cupboard but he doesn't care that the figures are occupied by real human beings with real feelings. This gets both he and Omri in trouble. This book is an interesting look at what happens when something that seems like it would be the coolest thing can turn out to not be so fun once reality hits. It is also interesting to see the empathy that Omri has for these small beings and how he tries to care for them and show Patrick how to care for them too. It also explores the dynamics of their friendship and touches lightly on the familial interactions between son and parents and brother to brother. While this is a book about boys, the story is not for boys alone. Girls will enjoy this story about a 'magical' experience. Boys will definitely love this and may even try locking up their action figures in every cupboard in the house to see what happens. It's a quick and interesting read for those who are easily distracted. I am concerned about the descriptions of all the historical characters especially the Native American (as one reviewer has been specific about the 'racist' nature of it.) So I would not recommend this for someone looking for an accurate description of Native Americans, cowboys or WWI medics but perhaps it could be used to start a discussion about stereotypes. Also I would not recommend this to someone looking for a fantasy novel. July 23, 2007 a new dimension It was interesting and exciting because the plot was unexpected. I liked the stories told by the characters from the cupboard and that they had past lives. Their daily lives were interesting such as the food they ate and the risks they faced. It's a good book to read for kids. April 12, 2007 The Indian in the Cupboard I discovered the story about the Indian in the Cupboard when I saw the film based on the book. I think the book is quite good, but I would like to have more illustrations, because I'm teacher of English for Spanish students and if you want to use the story for early ages (6-8) you'll need more illustrations. But in general I liked this book very much. March 7, 2007 Cornwall, NY Sixth Grader I am a sixth grader who experienced a magical journey after reading the famous book, The Indian in the Cupboard by Lynne Reid Banks and illustration by Brock Cole. The book takes you on a magical journey when Omri, who is celebrating his birthday,receives a plain old cupboard from his family and a plastic indian from his friend, Patrick. Omri loved cupboards and would find things to put in them. The cupboard however would not lock and his mother gives him a box with keys with all shapes and sizes. He tries them all until he finds the key that open the cupboard.While alone, he wonders what treasure to put in the cupboard. When Omri puts his plastic indian in the cupboard, he never imagined the magic that would come to life. His indian become the most important secret that he now must keep. Omri is so excited however that he shares his secret with his best friend, Patrick, who then makes things worst because he wants to use the "magical cupboard." This book really lets you feel the magic of the characters coming to life. The Indian in the Cupboard was made into a famous and classical movie in 1995. It is one of my favorite movies. Try reading The Return of the Indian, The Secret of the Indian, The Mystery of the Cupboard and The Key to the Indian. January 1, 2007 the indian in the cupboard This was one of the best books i have read in my life, it was humourus, sad, and makes you think. I liked the book alot, i only read the first one and i wouldn't mind reading the second! We read the book in class and we all laughed, and cried. I thought the book was a message, saying be careful of what you think and do. I will recommend this to my teacher, as a lesson in english, to come and post a review! :) December 4, 2006 A Pleasant Surprise! I checked this out from the library, mainly because of the limited selection of books on CD that would be appropriate for all of my children to listen. A friend had recommended it, but frankly she didn't do it justice. I was expecting a rather mindless, entertaining children's story. Instead I found it thought provoking and touching. The message that real maturity comes with real responsibility left me rethinking my parenting approach of waiting for maturity to happen before I give responsiblity. (Ok it's only children fiction I haven't acutally changed anything yet.) The other big surprise was the reading talent of the author. When I saw that the book was read by the author I was expecting a mediocre performance. As a regular audiobook listener I have to say Lynn Reid Banks is one of the best. November 16, 2006 Mrs.Mauri and her class review on Indian in the cupboard Everbody in Mrs.Mauri's class thinks that Indian in the cupboard is fantactic! You should read the book. And watch the movie. November 16, 2006 Indian in the cupboard Hi!My name is Charm.A book in fourth grade I read is Indian in the cupboard.To me the book is really halarious.A kid in any country or any state they should at least read the story.It has alot of langauges,country and indian. For more The Indian in the Cupboard reviews click here.
|
|||||
 |
|
|
||||
| Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Advertising | Contact Us | ||||||
| ©2005 Book Savers, All rights reserved. | ||||||
and Preschoolers