Snowflake Bentley (Caldecott Medal Book) Review

Manufacturer: Houghton Mifflin
Author(s): Jacqueline Briggs Martin

ISBN: 0395861624 EAN: 9780395861622
Binding: Hardcover
Pages: 32
Reading Level: Ages 4-8

Average Rating: 5 out of 5 Stars

Retail Price: ~~$17.00~~
Online Sale Price: $10.50
Save $6.50 Today!
* Price is subject to change.
This item qualifies for
Free Super Saver Shipping!

From the time he was a small boy, Wilson Bentley saw snowflakes as small miracles. And he determined that one day his camera would capture for others the wonder of the tiny crystal. Bentley's enthusiasm for photographing snowflakes was often misunderstood in his time, but his patience and determination revealed two important truths: no two snowflakes are alike; and each one is startlingly beautiful. His story is gracefully told and brought to life in lovely woodcuts, giving children insight into a soul who had not only a scientist's vision and perseverance but a clear passion for the wonders of nature. "Of all the forms of water the tiny six-pointed crystals of ice called snow are incomparably the most beautiful and varied." -- Wilson Bentley. SNOWFLAKE BENTLEY won the 1999 Caldecott Medal.

User Submitted Snowflake Bentley (Caldecott Medal Book) Reviews

April 22, 2008
something for every audience
There is something for everyone in this book. It can be difficult to find a non-fiction story, particularly an autobiography, told in a way that will fascinate the very young. This book does just that - but fascinates the more mature reader as well - including grade school students and adults. The story of Mr. Bentley is told in a very charming way with warm and pleasing pictures, and easy to read and follow text. You could learn quite a bit just by reading the story line. But as an added bonus, there were side bars that added even more historical information - so you could go back and read that yourself if your little one was not quite ready to hear that level of detail. These captions were not intrusive - the way I personally find the Magic School Bus captions to be - but rather side bars that you could read (or not read) at your own discretion. One of the nice things about Mr. Bentley's autobiography - is that you can learn some history, you can learn some science, and you can also simply enjoy the story of a man who was passionate about what he did.

February 18, 2008
Wonderful on so many levels.
The illustrations are simply beautiful-they always are on Caldecott Medal Books-and the story of "the snowflake man" is just as beautiful. I work as an instructional aide at an elementary school and used this book as an extension activity when the children made snowmen in art, studied snowstorms in science, and made predictions about how much snow we would get in math.
The children are intrigued by the story. Most of them had not heard of Snowflake Bentley and were surprised that it was a true story. The photos and drawings really pull them into the story and the fact that he invented a new way to photograph snowflakes, after a great deal of trial and error, really sends a wonderful message about never giving up. His parents helped by purchasing the expensive telescope/camera he needed to make himself an expert on snowflakes, and he gave his photos and information to universities and anyone else that wanted it.

A great story about commitment, perseverance, and real passion. Highly recommended!

February 13, 2008
Not as good as it gets...
When I see a book that has won the Caldecott Medal, I am usually wondering as I go in, what is so special about it? And here, in this case, being slightly unimpressed, it reminds me of the Oscars or the Emmys...what one man says is outstanding might not always be to my (or someone else's) taste.
This is a very good book, no doubt about that, written by Jacqueline Briggs Martin and illustrated by Mary Azarian (my favorite parts are the woodcut snowflakes), but it lacks the personal touch, the warmth of the other bio about "Snowflake Bentley" ~ "My Brother Loved Snowflakes," by Mary Bahr and illustrated by Laura Jacobsen.
The woodcut illustrations are well-done, but are not as much "fun" as the smooth, wonderfully colorful pastels and stencils of Ms. Jacobsen, and the story is told more matter-of-factly than the other book.
Even tho' I am pleased to have both in my library, having been a huge fan of Mr. Bentley for many years, I would go to the second tome more often than the first, if I were to ever pick them up for light reading...and to introduce my new Grandson to the wonders of Nature, especially the beauty of snow and ice and other microscopic sights.
Yes, as I sit and reflect on the fact that one is a so-called award winner and one is not, I have to say that, unlike other critics and "experts," I will continue to trust my own instincts ~ and my own heart.

January 23, 2008
Through a lens whitely
Last week when PK-4 came to the library for story time, I had picked out "Snow Friends" to read. Because the weather had been cold, I had the little ones put their hands aside their faces, concentrate on snow, and say, Believe, believe, believe. We said that a few times, then went on with the story. Well, it happened, three days later, in north Louisiana where we get snow once every two or three years, just a little dusting. But it snowed and one child told his teacher that they believed and it happened.

Willie Bentley was that way about snow. He was born in 1865 in Vermont, "in the heart of the snowbelt, where the annual snowfall is about 120 inches." As a boy he was fascinated with snow flakes, especially after his mother gave him an old microscope. "I found that snowflakes were masterpieces of design. No one design was ever repeated. When a snowflake melted...just that much beauty was gone...."

When he was fifteen he drew over 100 snow crystals each year for three winters, dismayed at the number he was losing. When he was seventeen his parents bought him a camera, even as his father pooh-poohed his foolishness. Its lens could magnify up to 3600 times the size of the snowflake. It took two years finally to photograph a snowflake, but it was the beginning of a historic record. (Do you know that it was Bentley who documented and proved that each snowflake is uniquely different, something every school child knows.)

Over the years he finally earned recognition for his photographs. Colleges bought copies for their collections, artists and designers bought his photographs for inspiration. As "the Snowflake Man,' he became world-renowned. When he was sixty-six other scientists--as Willie could be called--raised enough money to publish his book, "Snow Crystals," even now the first source people consult to learn about snow.

Yes, neighbors initially laughed at a teen who wanted to take pictures of snow in Vermont. However, his life's work and reputation proved them misguided. After his death they erected a statue in his honor in the center of town. Forty years after that, they established a museum to honor "Snowflake Bentley."

You, too, might giggle at the thought of a man so enamored of snow. I call it focus. Often the great contributors to making our world better or more beautiful are those who eschew scorn or laughter and keep right on working. There is an awe-filled lesson in these pages.

Caldecott Gold 1999: Jacqueline Briggs Martin, writer; Mary Azarian, illustrator

To see his book, click on this title: Snow Crystals by W. A. Bentley

January 14, 2008
Snowflake Bently
This is an excellent book for all ages of children. It will catch their attention because of the subject matter and how well it is written. For teachers it is a great read aloud book.

January 9, 2008
Glad I purchased! Great book!
The book is such an interesting one about the history of photographing snowflakes. The book has a unique format with snowflake patterns running along the edges. I'm not surprised that it was chosen years ago as a Caldecott winner. I purchased a number of copies to share with my grandchildren after we made 3-dimensional paper snowflakes together. It was a great accompaniment to a fun activity.

December 31, 2007
A MUST FOR ANY CLASS
THIS BOOK IS WONDERFUL IN EXPLAINING SNOWFLAKES AND HOW THEY WERE FIRST PHOTOGRAPHED. IT WAS A GREAT TOOL TO USE ALONG WITH THE WEBSITE FOR THIS GREAT PHOTOGRAPHER, SNOWFLAKE BENTLEY.

October 22, 2007
Unique as a Snowflake
Snowflake Bentley is a book my brothers love. It mixes reality with a story children relate to, it is fun for adults to read too. All in all, I'd say it is unique as a snowflake!

March 30, 2007
beautiful, must-have book
I love this book! It is a great science book, biography book, picture book, and more. A pleasure to view and read. We owe a debt to Snowflake Bentley for his selfless dedication to scientific research. We are also much indebted to the talented author and to the inspired illustrator for bringing us this story so beautifully. I have a copy for myself, sent one to my granddaughter, and sent another to my mother! Loved by all. Makes a great gift for book lovers, science lovers, and art lovers of any age, though targeted audience is probably picture book readers and younger elementary readers. Can't say enough about how worthwhile, well-done, and enjoyable this book is. You will want one of these in your personal library for the children in your life, and for yourself.

March 20, 2007
A good book for preschoolers
The four year old children in my care really enjoyed this book. I did a lot of introduction "This is a true story of a boy...etc." They loved it. Followed the next day with the actual photos and they couldn't get enough. It was a great intro into science experiments with water.

For more Snowflake Bentley (Caldecott Medal Book) reviews click here.